Document Type : Review Paper

Author

Department of Water Engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Jiroft, Jiroft, Iran.

10.22126/arww.2023.8195.1277

Abstract

Reservoir sedimentation is a serious challenge in many regions of the world and has severe consequences for water management, flood control, and generation of energy. The purpose of this paper is providing a valuable source of information on the reservoir sedimentation problem and reviewing the existing control strategies utilized globally against it. A wide range of sedimentation related problems were outlined. Different sediment management strategies were investigated with their main advantages and disadvantages. Special attention was devoted to the flushing technique as the most effective way of preserving the reservoirs’ storage capacity. As the main novelty of this study, a series of innovative complementary methods to improve the efficiency of sediment removal during the flushing operation was introduced. Based on the analysis, each sediment management strategy may be advantageous under certain circumstances, and successful implementation of such strategies needs regular monitoring and comprehensive recognition of the effective factors. The use of initiative structural methods, including those cited in this article, although they improve the flushing efficiency, they may come with some limitations that should be considered in practice. It is strongly recommended that such structural methods be taken into account in the first phases of dams’ design because they may influence the layout of dam structures. As conclusion, it was found that the progress is being made in successfully reducing and managing of sedimentation at reservoirs. New methods in combination with the flushing operation demonstrated significant performance in sediment removal from the reservoirs and restoring the corresponding storage. The study of this paper is recommended to interested researchers, dam owners, and water resources authorities.

Keywords

Abdipour A., Ahmadi H., Hosseini S.A., Physical model study for evaluation of jet impact on sediment flushing, Građevinar 70 (2018) 811-818.
Adeogun A.G., Sule B.F., Salami A.W., Cost effectiveness of sediment management strategies for mitigation of sedimentation at Jebba Hydropower reservoir, Nigeria, Journal of King Saud University-Engineering Sciences 30 (2018) 141-149.
Adongo T.A., Kyei-Baffour N., Abagale F.K., Agyare W.A., Assessment of reservoir sedimentation of irrigation dams in northern Ghana, Lake and Reservoir Management 36 (2020) 87-105.
Alemu M.M., Integrated watershed management and sedimentation, Journal of Environmental Protection 7 (2016) 490–494.
Al-Taiee T.M., Feasibility study of flushing sediments from Mosul reservoir, Iraq, Journal of Enviromental Hidrology 15 (2007) 1-16.
Althaus J.M., De Cesare G., Schleiss A.J., Sediment evacuation from reservoirs through intakes by jet-induced flow, Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 141 (2015) 04014078.
Althaus J.M., De Cesare G., Schleiss A.J., Release of suspension particles from a prismatic tank by multiple jet arrangements, Chemical Engineering Science 144 (2016) 153–164.
Andjelkovic A., Ristic R., Janic M., Djekovic V., Spalevic V., Genesis of Sediments and Siltation of the accumulation “Duboki Potok” of the Barajevska River Basin, Serbia, Journal of Environmental Protection and Ecology 18 (2017) 1735-1745.
Andredaki M., Georgoulas A., Hrissanthou V., Kotsovinos N., Assessment of reservoir sedimentation effect on coastal erosion in the case of Nestos River, Greece, International Journal of Sediment Research 29 (2014) 34-48.
Annandale G.W., Morris G.L., Karki P., Extending the life of reservoirs: sustainable sediment management for dams and run-of-river hydropower, The World Bank (2016).
Annandale G.W., Reservoir Sedimentation (Developments in Water Science), Elsevier (1987).
Annandale G.W., Reservoir Sedimentation, Encyclopedia of hydrological sciences, Anderson MG, McDonnell J (ed), John Wiley and Sons (2005).
Arnaud F., Piégay H., Schmitt L., Rollet A.J., Ferrier V., Béal D., Historical geomorphic analysis (1932–2011) of a by-passed river reach in process-based restoration perspectives, The Old Rhine downstream of the Kembs diversion dam (France, Germany), Geomorphology 236 (2015) 163-177.
Atkinson E., The feasibility of flushing sediments from reservoirs. TDR Project R5839, Report OD 137, HR Wallingford (1996).
Basson G., Bosman E., Vonkeman J., Reservoir sedimentation mitigation measures to deal with a severe drought at Graaff-Reinet, South Africa, E3S Web of Conferences 346 (2022) 1-14.
Basson G.R., and Rooseboom A., Sediment pass-through operations in reservoirs, In Proceedings of the International Conference on Reservoir Sedimentation, Fort Collins, CL, USA, (1996) 1107–1130.
Basson G.R., Management of siltation in existing and new reservoirs, 23rd Congress of the International Commission on Large Dams CIGB-ICOLD, Brasilia, (2009).
Beiramipour S., Qaderi K., Rahimpour M., Ahmadi M.M., Kantoush S.A., Effect of submerged vanes in front of circular reservoir intake on sediment flushing cone, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Water Management 174 (2021) 252-266.
Bertrand M., Piégay H., Pont D., Liébault F., Sauquet E., Sensitivity analysis of environmental changes associated with riverscape evolutions following sediment reintroduction: geomatic approach on the Drôme River network, France, International Journal of River Basin Management 11 (2013) 19-32.
Beyvazpour A., Daryaee M., Kashefipour S.M., Improvement of pressurized flushing efficiency by installing a single pile upstream of the orifice, Ain Shams Engineering Journal 12 (2021) 47-55.
Boeriu P., Roelvink D., Mulatu C.A., Thilakasiri C.N., Moldovanu A., Margaritescu M., Modeling the flushing process of reservoirs, Romanian Review Precision Mechanics, Optics and Mechatronics 40 (2011) 54-64.
Boillat J.L., Oehy C.H., Schleiss A., Reservoir sedimentation management in Switzerland, The 3rd World Water Forum, Challenges to the Sedimentation Management for Reservoir Sustainability, 378 (2003) 143-158.
Boughton D.A., East A., Hampson L., Kiernan J.D., Leiker S., Mantua N.J., Nicol C., Smith D., Urquhart K., Williams T.H., Harrison L.R., Removing a dam and re-routing a river: will expected benefits for steelhead be realized in Carmel River, California? NOAA Tech Memo 553 (2016) 1-85.
Brandt S.A., A review of reservoir desiltation, International Journal of Sediment Research 15 (2000) 321-342.
Chabalala D.T., Ndambuki J.M., Ilunga M.F., Determining the sources of sediment at different areas of the catchment: a case study of Welbedacht reservoir, South Africa, International Journal of Environmental and Ecological Engineering 11 (2017) 2058.
Chamoun S., De Cesare G., Schleiss A.J., Managing reservoir sedimentation by venting turbidity currents: A review, International Journal of Sediment Research 31 (2016) 195-204.
Chanson H., Extreme reservoir sedimentation in Australia: A review, International Journal of Sediment Research 13 (1998) 55-63.
Chaudhry M.A., and Rehman H.R., Worldwide experience of sediment flushing through reservoirs, Mehran University Research Journal of Engineering and Technology 31 (2012) 395-408.
Chen B.F., and Hung T.K., Dynamic pressure of water and sediment on Rigid dam, Journal of Engineering Mechanics 19 (1993) 1411-1433.
Chen J.G., Zhou W.H., Qiang C., Reservoir sedimentation and transformation of morphology in the lower yellow river during 10 year's initial operation of the Xiaolangdi reservoir, Journal of Hydrodynamics 24 (2012) 914-924.
Cigb I., Sedimentation and sustainable use of reservoirs and river systems, Bulletin 147, CRC Press (2023) 362.
Dargahi B., Reservoir sedimentation, A part of Encyclopedia of Earth Sciences Series, Springer, (2012) 628-649.
De Araújo J.C., Güntner A., Bronstert A., Loss of reservoir volume by sediment deposition and its impact on water availability in semiarid Brazil, Hydrological Sciences Journal 51 (2006) 157-170.
De Cesare G., Schleiss A., Hermann F., Innovative approaches to sediment management, Hydropower and Dams 3 (2011) 68-73.
Dendy F.E., Champion W.A., Wilson R.B., Reservoir sedimentation surveys in the US. Ackermann W.C., White G.F., Worthington E.B., Man-made lakes: their problems and environmental effects. American Geophysical Union, Washington DC, USA (1973) 847 pages.
DeNoyelles F., and Jakubauskas M., Current state, trend, and spatial variability of sediment in Kansas reservoirs, sedimentation in our reservoirs: causes and solutions, Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station (2008).
Dodaran A.A., Park S.K., Mardashti A., Noshadi M., Afsari M., Experimental investigation of Local Half-cone scouring against dam under the effect of localized vibrations in the sediment layers, Journal of Ocean Engineering and Technology 27 (2013) 107-113.
Emamgholizadeh S., Bina M., Fathi-Moghadam M., Ghomeshi M., Investigation and evaluation of the pressure flushing through storage reservoir, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences 1 (2006) 7-16.
Emamgholizadeh S., and Fathi-Moghdam M., Pressure flushing of cohesive sediment in large dam reservoirs, Journal of Hydrologic Engineering 19 (2014) 674 - 681.
Faghihirad S., Lin B., Falconer R., Application of a 3D layer integrated numerical model of flow and sediment transport processes to a reservoir, Water 7 (2015) 5239-5257.
Fan J., An overview of preserving reservoir storage capacity. Workshop on Reservoir Sedimentation at San Francisco Federal Regulatory Commission, Washington DC (1995).
Fan J., and Morris G.L., Reservoir sedimentation. II: Reservoir desiltation and long-term storage capacity, Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 118 (1992) 370-384.
Fang D., and Cao S., An experimental study on scour funnel in front of a sediment flushing outlet of a reservoir, Proceedings of the 6th Federal Interagency Sedimentation Conference, Las Vegas, USA, (1996) I.78-I.84.
Fathi-Moghadam M., Emamgholizadeh S., Bina M., Ghomeshi M., Physical modelling of pressure flushing for desilting of non-cohesive sediment, Journal of Hydraulic Research 48 (2010) 509-514.
Fu K.D., He D.M., Lu X.X., Sedimentation in the Manwan reservoir in the Upper Mekong and its downstream impacts, Quaternary International 18 (2008) 91-99.
Haghjouei H., Rahimpour M., Qaderi K., Kantoush S.A., Experimental study on the effect of bottomless structure in front of a bottom outlet on a sediment flushing cone, International Journal of Sediment Research 36 (2021) 335-347.
Hartmann S., Knoblauch H., Badura H., De Cesare G., Steinich C., Schneider J., ALPRESERV - Sustainable Sediment Management in Alpine Reservoirs considering ecological and economical aspects: Pilot Actions and Database, Institute of Hydraulic Engineering and Water Resources Management, Eigenverlag, Germany, (2008).
Hassanzadeh Y., The removal of reservoir sediment, Water International 20 (1995) 151-154.
Heckmann T., Haas F., Abel J., Rimböck A., Becht M., Feeding the hungry river: Fluvial morphodynamics and the entrainment of artificially inserted sediment at the dammed river Isar, Eastern Alps, Germany, Geomorphology 291 (2017) 128-142.
Heidarzadeh N., and Motieinejad O.M., Evaluating sedimentation effect on reservoirs water quality: A case study, Shahriyar reservoir, International Journal of Environmental Sciecnce and Technology 14 (2017) 2623-2636.
Hotchkiss R.H., and Huang X. Hydrosuction sediment removal systems (HSRS): principles and field test, Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 121 (1995) 479–489.
Huang Y., Wang J., Yang M., Unexpected sedimentation patterns upstream and downstream of the three gorges reservoir: Future risks, International Journal of Sediment Research 34 (2019) 108-117.
Imanshoar F., Hassanzadeh Y. and Aalami M.T., An introduction to environmental impacts of sedimentation and erosion due to dam's construction, Workshop on Reservoir Sedimentation Control. Regional Centre on Urban Flood Management, Karaj, Iran, (2009).
Juez C., Battisacco E., Schleiss A.J., Franca M.J., Assessment of the performance of numerical modeling in reproducing a replenishment of sediments in a water-worked channel, Advances in Water Resources 92 (2016) 10–22.
Jugović C.J., Strohmeier S., Schuster G., Nachtnebel H.P., Hydraulic flushing of alpine reservoirs- model study. International Symposium of water management and hydraulic engineering, Ohrid/Macedonia (2009).
Juracek K.E., The aging of America’s reservoirs: In reservoir and downstream physical changes and habitat implications, Journal of American Water Resources Association 51 (2015) 168–184.
Kantoush S.A., Sumi T., River morphology and sediment management strategies for sustainable reservoir in Japan and European Alps, Annuals Disaster Prevention Research Institute Annuals Kyoto University 53 (2010) 821-839.
Kantoush S.A., Sumi T., Suzuki T., Murasaki M., Impacts of sediment flushing on channel evolution and morphological processes: Case study of the Kurobe River, Japan, River Flow (2010a) 1165-1173.
Kantoush S.A., Sumi T., Kubota A., Suzuki T., Impacts of sediment replenishment below dams on flow and bed morphology of river, First International Conference on Coastal Zone Management of River Deltas and Low Land Coastlines (2010b).
Katano I., Negishi J.N., Minagawa T., Kawaguchi Y., Kayaba Y., Effects of sediment replenishment on riverbed environments and macroinvertebrate assemblages downstream of a dam, Scientific Reports 11 (2021) 1-17.
Kondolof G.M., Gao Y., Annandale G.W., Morris G.L., Jiang E., Zhang J., Cao Y., Carling P., Fu K., Guo Q., Hotchkiss R., Peteuil C., Sumi T., Wang H.W., Wang, Z., Wei Z., Wu B., Wu C., Yang C.T., Sustainable sediment management in reservoirs and regulated rivers: Experiences from five continents, Earth’s Future 2 (2014) 256–280.
Kong D., Latrubesse E.M., Miao C., Zhou R., Morphological response of the Lower Yellow River to the operation of Xiaolangdi Dam, China, Geomorphology 350 (2020) 106931.
Kummu M., and Varis O., Sediment related impacts due to upstream reservoir trapping, the Lower Mekong River, Geomorphology, 85 (2007) 275-293.
Lai J.S., and Shen H.W., Degradation flushing processes in reservoir, Proceedings of the 26th Congress of the IAHR, HYDRA 2000, Vol 4: Gardiner J., (Ed), The Hydraulics of Water Resources and Their Development, London, Thomas Telford Services Ltd (1995) P. 266-271.
Lai J.S., Hydraulic flushing for reservoir, Dissertation, University of California (1994).
Lai J.S., and Shen H.W., Flushing sediment through reservoirs, Journal of Hydraulic Research 34 (1996) 237-255.
Lin J., Kantoush S.A., Sumi T., Takemon Y., Comprehensive assessment of sediment replenishment in Naka River: Hydrological, morphological, and ecological perspectives, Journal of Japan Society of Civil Engineers, Ser. B1 (Hydraulic Engineering) 77 (2021) 379-384.
Madadi M.R., Rahimpour M., Qaderi K., Sediment flushing upstream of large orifices: an experimental study, Flow Measurement and Instrumentation 52 (2016) 180-189.
Madadi M.R., Rahimpour M., Qaderi K., Improving the pressurized flushing efficiency in reservoirs: an experimental study, Water Resources Management 31 (2017) 4633-4647.
Madadi Z., Ahmadi M., Rahimpour M., Experimental study on the effect of circular jet on sediment flushing in reservoirs, Journal of Hydraulics 13 (2019) 111-120.
Mahmood K., Reservoir sedimentation: Impact, Extent, and Mitigation. World Bank Technical Paper WTP-71, The World Bank, Washington, D.C., USA, (1987).
Mikhailov V.N., Kravtsova V.I., Isupova M.V., Impact of reservoirs on the hydrological regime and morphology of the lower reaches and delta of the Zambezi River (Mozambique), Water Resources 42 (2015) 170-185.
Miyagawa Y., Sumi T., Takemon Y., Kobayashi S., Effects of sediment replenishment on riverbed material size distribution and attached algal biomass in the downstream reaches of a dam, Hydrological Research Letters 11 (2017) 114-120.
Moges M.M., Abay D., Engidayehu H., Investigating reservoir sedimentation and its implications to watershed sediment yield: The case of two small dams in data‐scarce upper Blue Nile Basin, Ethiopia, Lakes & Reservoirs: Research & Management 23 (2018) 217-229.
Morris G.L., Classification of management alternatives to combat reservoir sedimentation, Water 12 (2020) 861.
Morris G.L., Management alternatives to combat reservoir sedimentation, International Workshop on Sediment Bypass Tunnels, ETH Zurich, Switzerland (2015) 181-193.
Morris G.L., Reservoir sedimentation and sustainable development in India: problem scope and remedial strategies, Sixth International Symposium on River Sedimentation, Management of Sediment: Philosophy, Aims, and Techniques, New Delhi, Balkema, Rotterdam, (1995) 53-61.
Morris G.L., Annandale G., Hotchkiss R., Reservoir Sedimentation. In: Garcia M. (Ed), Sedimentation Engineering: Processes, Measurements, Modeling, and Practice, Reston, VA, USA, ASCE; (2008), P. 579-612.
Morris G.L., and Fan J., Reservoir sedimentation handbook: Design and management of dams, Reservoirs and Watershed for Sustainable Use (Electronic Version), McGraw Hill, New York (2010).
Mulatu C.A., Analysis of reservoir sedimentation process using empirical and mathematical method: Case study–Koga irrigation and watershed management project, Ethiopia, Nile Basin Water Science Engineering Journal 5 (2012) 1-13.
Naderi S., Daryaee M., Kashefipour S.M., Zayeri M., Numerical and Experimental Study of Flow Pattern due to a Plate Installed Upstream of Orifice in Pressurized Flushing of Dam Reservoirs. Iranian Journal of Science and Technology, Transactions of Civil Engineering 46 (2022) 4593-4603.
Niu Y., and Shah F.A., Economics of optimal reservoir capacity determination, sediment management, and dam decommissioning, Water Resources Research 57 (2021) 1-18.
Ock G., Jang C.L., Kim B., Choi M., A review on sediment replenishment to river channel for natural recovery of regulated rivers below large dams, Journal of Korea Water Resources Association 52 (2019) 835-844.
Ock G., Sumi T., Takemon Y., Sediment replenishment to downstream reaches below dams. Implementation perspectives, Hydrological Research Letter 7 (2013) 54-59.
Oehy C., Effects of obstacles and jets on reservoir sedimentation due to turbidity currents, Lausanne, EPFL-LCH (2003).
Okano M., Kikui M., Ishida H., Sumi T., Reservoir sedimentation management by coarse sediment replenishment below dams, Ninth International Symposium on River Sedimentation (2004).
Palmieri A., Shah F., Annandale G.W., Dinar A., Eand engineering evaluation of alternative strategies for managing sedimentation in storage reservoirs: RESCON approach, Washington DC: World Bank Group, (2003).
Paul T.C., and Dhillon G.S., Sluice dimensioning for reservoirs, International Water Power and Dam Construction 40 (1988) 40-44.
Paulo F.A., Abreu A.S., Prá M.D., Endres L.A.M., Ferla R., Teixeira E.D., Experimental study of pressure flushing of non-cohesive sediment through slotted pipe bottom outlet, Brazilian Journal of Water Resources 26 (2021) 1-11.
Podolak C.J.P., and Doyle M.W., Reservoir sedimentation and storage capacity in the United States: Management needs for the 21st Century, Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 141 (2015) 1-5.
Rachelly C., Friedl F., Boes R.M., Weitbrecht V., Morphological response of channelized, sinuous gravel‐bed rivers to sediment replenishment, Water Resources Research 57 (2021) 1-18.
Rahmani V., Kastens J.H., DeNoyelles F., Jakubauskas M.E., Martinko E.A., Huggins D.H., Gnau C., Liechti P.M., Campbell S.W., Callihan R.A., Blackwood A.J., Examining storage capacity loss and sedimentation rate of large reservoirs in the central US Great Plains, Water 10 2 (2018) 1-17.
Rajabipour N., Physical modeling of dams bottom outlet blockage and providing solutions to getting it out, Dissertation, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Iran, (2017).
Randle T.J., Morris G.L., Tullos D.D., Weirich F.H., Kondolf G.M., Moriasi D.N., Annandale G.W., Fripp J., Minear J.T., Wegner D.L., Sustaining United States reservoir storage capacity: Need for a new paradigm, Journal of Hydrology 602 (2021) 126686.
Ren S., Zhang B., Wang W.J., Yuan Y., Guo C., Sedimentation and its response to management strategies of the Three Gorges Reservoir, Yangtze River, China, Catena199 (2021) 105096.
Roca M., Tarbela dam in Pakistan, Case study of reservoir sedimentation, International Conference on Fluvial Hydraulics, River Flow, Costa Rica (2012).
Scheuerlein H., Tritthart M., Nunez Gonzalez F., Numerical and physical modeling concerning the removal of sediment deposits from reservoirs, Conference Proceeding of Hydraulic of Dams and River Structures, Tehran, Iran, (2004) 328-341.
Schleiss A.J., Sedimentation of reservoirs, Bobrowsky P.T. (Ed) Encyclopedia of Natural Hazards, Encyclopedia of Earth Sciences Series, Springer, Dordrecht (2013) 901-905.
Schleiss A.J., DeCesare G., Althaus J.J., Reservoir sedimentation and sustainable development, International Conference on Erosion, Transport and Deposition of Sediments, Lausanne, (2008) 23-28.
Schleiss A.J., Franca M.J., Juez C., De Cesare G., Reservoir sedimentation, Journal of Hydraulic Research 54 (2016) 595-614.
Sedláček J., Bábek O., Grygar T.M., Lenďáková Z., Pacina J., Štojdl J., et al., A closer look at sedimentation processes in two dam reservoirs, Journal of Hydrology 605 (2022) 127397.
Sen S.P., and Srivastava A., Flushing of sediment from small reservoir. Sixth International Symposium on River Sedimentation, Management of Sediment: Philosophy, Aims, and Techniques, New Delhi, Balkema, Rotterdam, (1995) 885-901.
Sloff C.J., Reservoir sedimentation: A literature survey, committee on hydraulic and geotechnical engineering, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands (1991) 126.
Stähly S., Franca M.J., Robinson C.T., Schleiss A.J., Sediment replenishment combined with an artificial flood improves river habitats downstream of a dam, Scientific Reports 9 (2019) 1-8.
Sumi T., and Hirose T., Water Storage, Transport, and Distribution – Accumulation of Sediment in Reservoirs, Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems (EOLSS) (2009).
Tigrek S., and Aras T., Reservoir sediment management. London, United Kingdom: CRC Press (2012).
Tolouei E., West J.R., Billam J., Sedimentation and desiltation in the Sefid-Roud reservoir, Iran, Geomorphology and Sedimentology of Lakes and Reservoirs. McManus J., Duck R.W., (eds), John Wiley and Sons Ltd. (1993) 125–138.
Wang Z., and Hu C., Strategies for managing reservoir sedimentation, International Journal of Sediment Research 24 (2009) 369-84.
White W.R., Flushing of sediments from reservoirs, World Commission on Dams (2001).
White W.R., and Bettes R., The feasibility of flushing sediments through reservoirs, Symposium on challenges in African hydrology and water resources, IAHS Harare, Zimbabwe (1984).
Wildi W., Environmental hazards of dams and reservoirs, NEAR Curriculum in Natural Environmental Science, Terre Environ 88 (2010) 187–197.
Xie Y.H., Yue T., Xin‐sheng C., Feng L., Zheng‐miao D., The impact of Three Gorges Dam on the downstream eco‐hydrological environment and vegetation distribution of East Dongting Lake, Ecohydrology 8 (2015) 738-746.
Zhang X., Zhang Y., Zhang L., Analysis on reservoir desilting by spiral flow, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Mechanic Automation and Control Engineering, IEEE, 2 (2011) 1961-1963.